I recently found⛦ myself absorbed in “The Ungovernable City,” Vincent Cannato’s extraordinary account of New York in the Lindsay years. He paints a vivid picture of a school system spiraling out of control.
In 1970, The New York Times desc꧙ribed our schools as 🍸plagued by chaos and disorder, where “thugs engaged in widespread intimidation, shakedowns, extortion and violent assault.”
At Samuel J. Tilden HS in Brooklyn, 2𒊎,000 students had to be evacuated in 1969 after a student threw a Molotov cocktail through a window. A year later, the school was closed again when students set off stink bombs in the cafeteria and assaulted police officers.
In retrospect, it’s hard to belﷺieve how long New Yorkers put up with that unconscionable situation. Yet the schools were only beginning their nosedive.
In 1986, the old Board of Education began to keep♍ graduation-rate statistics. It found that fewer than half the city’s students were graduating in four years. For the next 15 years, the number barely budged.
Thirty years after the r🍌iots in📖 its cafeteria, Tilden HS still endured a culture of violence and academic failure. Many students regularly carried guns and knives.
At Adlai Stevenson HS in The Bronx, gang fights in the late ’90s were s꧑o common that teachers regularly pulled down iron gates from the hallway ceilings to contain rioting. The only way to protect students was to make them prisoners of their own school.
Not surprisingly, the school was steeped in f💜ailure in other ways as well. Only one in three students there graไduated on time — and many never did.
The students🥂 forced to attend these schools had no alternative tꦅo walking through dangerous hallways. No choice but to endure what was likely an inferior education, judging by the numbers.
And a maze 🌌of union contracts and byzantine laws and regulations prevented par📖ents from doing anything about it. They were all but prohibited from sending their kids to high schools outside of their districts. The gates were closed around them.
Those parents and students didn’t know there co𝕴uld be another way. Because for decades, there wasn’t one. The forces of self-interest had made sure of that. Not because they didn’t care about children, but because they cared more about themselves, or the people who signed their paychecks or the ones who got them their jobs.
It’s especially worth reflecting on this dꦛuring an election year. Whoever sets the city’s education agenda for the next four🤡 years had best recall how bad things once were — and how easy it would be to relive the disasters of the past.
There are powerful adults whosꦬe control over our ཧstudents’ education was loosened when Michael Bloomberg became mayor. They’re now vying to regain their grip.
On behalf of our 🦋1.1 million New York City 🌼students — two of them, my grandchildren — I want to make sure we’re all aware of what’s at stake.
No critic, candidate or union chief will be honest enough to say that they want to return the system to the old status𓆏 quo. But if you listen carefully, you’ll hear euphemisms for some very bad ideas.
Unions, activists and the candidates they support have been calling for ൩moratoriums on replacing failing schools with smaller schools and charters. Some call for community approval before the Department of Education can act. But what would have happened if that had been the policy all along?
In 2002, the graduation rate at 22 of the city’s large high schools was 38 percent. Some had graduation rates under 25 percent. These schools’ culture of failure stretched back years and even decades. They had ꩵdefied a catalog of remediation strategies. They needed to be reconceived.
And that’s what we did. After꧂ extensive community input, we phased each one out and re🅷placed it with a collection of small schools specializing in everything from architecture to zoology.
All e♔mployees at the old schools had to re-apply for their jobs, with principals placed in charge of re-hiring. The teachers union didn’t like it, but for the students and families who attended the new schools, it was a brand new day.
Today, the culture on those 22 campuses has changed dramatically. The average graduation rate rose from 38�♔� percent in 2002 to 68 percent last year.
Schools characterized by chaos and failure stretching back to the ’60s have been re-born. At Brooklyn’s once-beleaguered Samuel J. Tilden HS, the graduation rate rose from 42 percent in 2002 to 78 percent last year. The dropout rate has fallen by half, and crime is down 93 percent.
What would have happened if we hadn’t revamped Tilden HS? Where wouꩵld those students be today?
Think of that when you hear someone🍰 call for community approval of school phase-outs, for limits on new charters or for moratoriums on co-locating small schools in a building.
According to MDRC, a widely-respected national research group, students who attend our new small schools have graduation rates 10 points higher than their peers at other schools. Better still, graduation rates for black males are almost 14 points🎉 higher at our small schools. We’ve significantly reduced the racial achievement gap in these schools — and found a model for success that has eluded America’s school sys𒁃tems for generations.
At schools across the c🧸ity, we’ve raised the gates that once imprisoned our students.
Dennis M. Walcott is the city’s schools chancellor. Adapted from his speech this week to the Association for a Better New York.