Kamala Harris was afraid Pa. Gov. Josh Shapiro would steal the ‘spotlight,’ alienate anti-Israel progressives: sources
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro broke his silence about not joining the 2024 Democratic ticket as the vice presidential candidate — with sources attributing presidential nominee Kamala Harris’ snub to her fear that he would steal the “spotlight” and alienate the party’s progressive base over his support for Israel.
Shapiro said Harris and her “exceptionally strong” VP pick, Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, had his “enthusiastic support” — and added that his work was “far from finished” in Pennsylvania.
“Over the next 90 days, I look forward to traveling all across the Commonwealth to unite Pennsylvanians behind Kamala Harris’ campaign to defeat Donald Trump, become the 47th President of the United States, and build a better future for our country,” he said in a statement .
Political consultant Hank Sheinkopf told The Post that Shapiro was too hot to pick as Harris’ running mate because of his pro-Israel record, and that Waltz was a safer ♒choice.
“The tiꦗcket would have been too pro-Israel. Harris doesn’t need a battle over Israel-Gaza,” said Sheinkopf, who worked on Bill Clinton’s re-election campaign.
Democrats are not as reflexively pro-Israel as in th🌳e past, he noted, and Harris needs the votes of pro-Palestinian progressives who are highly critical of Israel.
“She has to keep the progressives in the 💮fold,” Sheinkopf said.
That sentiment was also expressed by several Republican lawmakers — including House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) and Walz’s opponent, GOP vice presidential candidate JD Vance.
“I think that clearly was a major factor, is that she was reluctant to put a vice presidential nominee on the ticket with Jewish heritage because they’re having a spli🧔t in the Democratic Party,” Johnson said in following Harris’ announcement.
“They have a pro-Palestinian, in some cases pro-Hamas wing of the Democratic Party. Sadly for Josh Shapiro, ღbecause of his heritage, I think that is the reason he wa🔴s overlooked,” he added.
“I genuinely feel bad that for days, maybe weeks, [Shapiro] actually had to run away from his Jewish herita🐭ge because of wha𓆏t the Democrats are saying about [him],” Vance told The Post on Tuesday.
“The fact that that race — the vice presidential 𒐪race on the Democratic side — became so focused on his ethnicity, I think it’s absolutely disgraceful, and it’s insulting to Americans, whatever background you’re from,” heꦕ added.
Earlier Tuesday, Vance predicted that a Shapiro snub would occur “out of antisemitism in their own caucus and in their own party” during anꦫ interview the GOP veep pick did with conservative radio host Hugh Hewitt.
But a𝐆nother Democratic operative who spoke with The Post di♏smissed the notion of anti-Israel sentiment playing a role.
Follow The Post’s coverage on Kamala Harris’ running mate Tim Walz:
- Kamala Harris chooses Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz as ru𒀰nning mate
- Who is Tim Walz, Kamala Harris’ VP pick?
- Tim Walzꦉ signed laws catering to illegal migrant꧒s, giving them free health care, tuition
- Trump team says it’s relieved Kamala H꧂arris chose ‘extrem🌞ist’ Tim Walz: ‘An easy opponent’
- Edit🐈💃orial: Kamala Harris bows to the radicals by picking lefty Tim Walz as her running mate
“I think if the flak he’d taken regarding Israel had been a stronger consideration, he wouldn’t haꦐve made it this far at all,” the operative said of𒊎 Shapiro.
The Biden-Harris administration has nonetheless faced plummeting sup📖port from Muslim and Arab Americans ov♕er its backing of the Israeli government in its war in Gaza against Hamas.
Nearly 20% of Democratic primary voters in Minnesota, for example, declined to vote for Presiꦗdent Biden and put down “uncommitted” in protest of US support for Israel’s war effort.
Others had also previously speculated that the Jewish gover📖nor was facing opposition for his pro-Israel stance or outright antisemitism from within his own party, with critics from the left flank smearing Shapiro as “Genocide Josh.”
“These Progressives don’t want a Jew. Let’s say it out loud,” Rep. Jared Moskowitz (D-Fla.) said in response to reports of bac🍷klash to Shapiro, who has both defended Israel against its ✅critics and admonished some members of the Israeli government over its settlements in the West Bank.
Even the governor tried to distance himself from an op-ed he wrote as a collꦕege student that divulged his former service in the Israel Defense Forces as a volunteer and characterization of Palestinians as opposed to peace talks.
“I was 20,” Shapiro said when first asked for c🍃omment last week 🎶on the article.
Shapiro in his Tuesday statemen𓆏t characterized the decision as “deeply personal” on both of their parts — but one the Democratic operative also told The Post that Harris was aware the Pennsylvania governor could outshine her.
“My honest sense is that Harris had a concern that Shapiro would overshadow her and be the spotlight of the ticket here,” the operative said, confirming earlier reports of the younger Democrat’s ability to upstage some of his party’s national leaders.
“What this pick came down to was, more or less, vibes,” the operative added, describing Walz’s as a “Midwestern do-no-harm vibe.”
Shapiro was passed over three days after a puzzling video already describing him as Harris’ No. 2 leaked online from the X account of Philadelphia Mayor Cherelle Parker.
It also came after Sen. John Fetterman (D-Pa.) privately relayed an “unvarnished assessment” to the Harris campaign that Shapiro was laser-focused on his own personal ambitions, Politico reported, which he observed during their time together on Pennsylvania’s Board of Pardons.
Two other sources that the Parker team’s video and Fetterman’s warning “solidified” Harris’ choice of Walz.
Some﷽ GOP candidates and lawmakers expressed relief at the decision.
“I would have preferred him to not be the choice,” said Pennsylvania Senate Republican candidate Dave McCormick.
“It would’ve complicated things.”
“The pick of Tim Walz, which was announced this morning, is further evidence to me of national Democrats’ turn to the left,” added Senate Minority Whip John Thune (R-SD), implying the GOP could make inroads with more moderate voters “on pretty much every level.”
Former President Donald Trump in appeared elated following the pick, saying bluntly: “THANK YOU!”
