Political and religious ads were banned entirely from the transit syš§østem following a fierce debate on Wednesday, about a week after a federal judge ordered the MTA to allow anti-Muslim posters.
The new policy, which is effective immediately, wasā passed by the MTA board in a 9-2 voź¦°te.
āHateful speechš¦© is not harmless speech. Only a fool or rogue would argue otherwise,ā said Charles Moerdler, an MTA board member and Holocaust survivor who voted for the new policy.
āāMein Kampfā was a precursor to genocide. Hateful speech fuels the fire of š ·death and destruction.ā
Only paid commercial advertising, public-service announcements and government messages will be allowš§øed. There are currently no political ads up in the subway system.
Manhattan federal Judge John Koeltl ruled on April 21 that the MTA had to run a bus ad from the American Freedom Defense Initiative, which had suedā arguing freedom of speech.
The adš„ featured a Muslim man with his face covered and the Hamas quote: āKš»illing Jews is Worship that draws us close to Allah.ā Below that it said, āThatās His Jihad. Whatās yours?ā
Pamela Geller, who heads the AFDI, šŖwas seething at the proposed new policy. āYou cannot shut this down,ā she said during theš¼ meeting. āYou call my ads hateful. These are actual quotes from high-profile Muslims. We need to have this conversation.ā
The MTA said it takeź§s in less than $1 million a year from political ads, while its tšotal ad revenue was $140 million in 2014.
Some MTA officials were against the new policy. āI think weāve given them more play than they would have gotten if we just ran thešm,ā said Ira Greenberg. āWhat makes us civilized is that we do not react to these uncivilized ads.ā
Andrew Albert, who represents the subway and bus riderās on the board, also oāpposed the new policy.
āI think it says that New Yorkers are not as smart as people in other cities and other transit systems ā that we canāt determine the difference between hate speech and political spšeech and hemorrhoid-related ads,ā said Albert, who chairs the Transit Riders Council.
āI think we allź¦ know what the ads are and can interpret them well. New Yorkers are pretty sharp in that regard.ā
Board member Allen Capšpelli, who voted no, sšaid the subway has been an open public forum for a century.
āš It is backward thinking, the kind of thinking that has led us over the years to lose case after case in this regard,ā he said.