Opinion

New York taxpayers’ gift to Elon Musk

Tesla CEO Elon Musk just struck an astronomical deal for $2.6 billion (yes, with a ā€œbā€) in pay. Good for him ā€” but itā€™s worth noting that New York taxpayers have helped fund šŸ½a hšŸŒ³efty chunk of this biggest-ever corporate compensation package.

Weā€™re thinking of the $750 million in public funds that Gov. Andrew Cuomo has shelled oušŸŒøt as part of his Buffalo Billion (now Billion-and-a-Half) program to build a factory and infrastructure for solar panel maker SolarCity ā€” which was headed to bankruptcy until Tesla acquired it.

You paid for Teslaā€™s factory ā€” saving the electric car compā™“any the cost. And now Tesla can use those savings to help cover Muskā€™s deal.

Itā€™s a stomach-turning thought: New York taxpayers are being fleeced to help pay billions to a man already worth an estimated $20 billion. It should send shivers up the spine of every single one of the sšŸƒtateā€™sšŸƒ 19.9 million residents.

Worse, Cuomoā€™s promised ā€œreturn on investmentā€ on that $750 million ā€” thousands of jobs for economically ailing Buffalo ā€” has yet to materializšŸ’Ÿe.

The plant, which began operating last year, now empš“°loys just a few hundred workers, and its future ršŸŒžemains uncertain. Indeed, the Buffalo area actually lost nearly 5,000 jobs between December 2016 and December 2017.

Meanwhile, Cuomoā€™s Buffalo Billion did generate a whole mountain of corruption: His former top aide, Joe Percoco, was convicted just this month. Another key player, SUNY Polytechnic honcho Alain Kaloyeros, faces trial in Junź¦‡e.

True, Musk will only collect his full $2.6 billion (in the form of stock options) if Tesla hits growth targets,ā™ˆ and some are quite ambitious. But under the terms of the deal, he could actually earn as much as $55 billion (about 1 million times as much as a starting teacherā€™ź¦›s annual salary) if the firm meets all the goals.

And ifāœƒ Tesla does well enough to pay him that much, why would it need a $750 million handout from New York taxpayers?

Alas, this is Cuomoā€™s sorry approach to economic development in New York: Bathe favored industries in taxpayer cash but ban a terrific sourcā™›e of new upstate jobs, fracking (even as the rest of the nation thrives from it). Push through sky-high minimum wage laws that make it too expensive to hire new workers and keep taxes in the stratosphere, discouraging wealthy job creators. (Heā€™s now moving to hike taxes again this year.)

No wonder the upstate region has seen little growth ā€” and even job losses. No wonder its share of the stateā€™s population continues to plummet, as a new City Planning analysšŸŽ€is of census data shows.

What a tragic bottom line: New York suffers while the billionaiā˜‚res grow richer.