Swing States 2024
Politics

Senate Republicans more optimistic about red flips this election than Mitch McConnell’s PAC

Is a red wave coming to the Senate in November?

Those who remember the optimistic predictions two years ago f💝rom the National Repuဣblican Senatorial Committee under the stewardship of then-chair Rick Scott of Florida may feel a sense of déjà vu — or PTSD, depending on their point of view.

But the NRSC, now helmed by Montana Sen. Steve Daines, is every bit as hopeful Repubღlicans have a number of pickup opportunities on this year’s electoral map that could, if all goes as their internal polling projects, garner them 53 Senate seats.

Mitch McConnell walking from the Senate Chamber to his office at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, DC on September 25, 2024, amidst discussions on government funding bill
McConnell has long fretted over the quality of GOP candidates recruited to run for Senate in the Trump era. Getty Images

If they succeed, they’ll have built a firewall to hold up for GOP priorities even if Democrats win the White House and Tim Walz was positioned to cast deciding votes on legislation.

The NRSC memo leaked soon after a much more pessimistic document came from Mitch McConnell’s Senate Leadership Fund, which warned of head𒁏winds facing not only the Senate slate but Donald Trump himself in key states.

McConnell warned personally about “candidate quality” issues in 2022, and while the Senate leader’s been quiet this cycle, the morose memo did plenty of talking this week.

On a number of races, the internal polls and the analysis are diametrically opposed, with Ohio providing the mo𓃲st vivid divergence.

Whereꦡas the SLF read had Republican challenger Bernie Moreno down 6 points to Democratic perennial Sen. Sherrod Brown, the NRSC polling shows Moreno up 2 points against the free-spending incumbent.

The NRSC optimism extends to the top of the ticket, where it sees Tru♐mp 11 points ahead of Kamala Harris in Ohio, nearly triple the 4-point edge the GOP nominee has in the SLF’s assessment.

Wisconsin is also in the NRSC pickup column, with Eric Hಌovde “narrowly ahead of Tammy Baldwin 48% to 47% in a head-to-head matchup” and tied with the long-serving senator in a multi-candidate mix.

Senator Rick Scott speaking at a town-hall meeting in Braselton, Georgia, in 2024, holding a microphone in support of Republican policies
Sen. Rick Scott headed up the NRSC in the 2022 midterms, which failed to deliver a GOP majority in the upper chamber. AP

Hovde has improved h♌is favorables and gained 4 points in the 🍌last two polls. 

While the spread here isn’t as striking as Ohio, the SLF saw Hovde 1 point doꦓwn in the blue-wall bastion. 

“Hovde has a clear opportunity to continue his growth and consolidate support while driving Baldwin’s negatives up and her position on the ballot down,” the NRSC memo sa🌊ys.

Speaking of blue-wall stat𒀰es, the two groups diverge sharply on the viability of Mike Rogers’ bid to pick up a Democratic open seat in Michigan.

While the SLF spo♓tlighted an 8-point lead for Democrat Elissa Slotkin, the NRSC depicts a dead heat on a head-to-head ballot test, with Slotkin up by 1 in a multi-candidate scenario. 

“Rogers’s name awareness and image have continued to show improvement across the state — 40% say they are favorable of Rogers and 38% say unfavorable. He has maintaine🎃d this marginal net positive image since September. Rogers’s numbers are closing the gap between him and Slotkin and a♔s these trends continue, we see a very attainable victory for our candidate,” the NRSC notes.

The two groups agree ♍about Montana flipping, with Tim Sheehy up 8 points against incumbent Jon Tester.

But whereas the SLF sees it as a 4-point lead, the NRSC doubles that spread to 8 points, as Tester�♐� is underwater and thoroughly defined to the electorate, with only 6% of those in Big Sky Country with no opinion or knowledge of the Democratic senator.

And iꦛn their own ways, both groups provide happy talk about Larry Hogan and vague numbers about his lon🌳gshot Senate bid in Maryland. 

“Larry Hogan historically closes strong. While the polls remain volatile, this is a margin of error election,” the NRSC argues, with a “huge undecided population in Maryland that trusts the Governor’s leadership but struggles with the idea of a Republican Senate.”

With public polls showing Ange𒉰la Alsobrooks up 9.5 points on average, it is incumbent on the former GOP governor to mobilize that “huge” and “struggling” cohort. Yet the NRSC argues “the G🌠overnor knew this would be the challenge from the very beginning and has strategized accordingly.”