Lois Weiss

Lois Weiss

Real Estate

Vying for a Manhattan forever-home, retailers are racing to buy their storefronts

Prime city retail storefr♏onts are so rare that businesses are opting for the nuclear option — buying. 

Kering and Prada bought thꦡeir stores on Fifth Avenue last year for $835 million and🤡 $963 million respectively. Now, Uniqlo is purchasing 100,000 square feet of retail it already occupies at 660 Fifth Ave. from Vornado.

Uniqlo bought one 17,250-square-foot portion of the retail condo, for $350 million. The deal prices the 𒆙space at $20,237 per foot — and gives them a forever home.  

Coach store front at 685 5th Ave, NY, featuring a large mural with Edie Campbell, Lexi Boling, Gigi Hadid, Joan Smalls, Lily Aldridge, Helena Wong, and Tom Mandrake.
At the base of the new Mandarin Oriental Residences at 685 Fifth Ave., brokers are marketing forever homes to big fashion houses. It’s currently housing brands like Coach and Tag Heuer. Zandy Mangold

“Smart retailers are saying before the rent getℱs out of control again, ღlet me own it,” said Steven Soutendijk of Cushman & Wakefield. “We have the lowest availability since 2011 or 2012.”

In the base of the new Mandarin Oriental Residences at 685 Fifth Ave., brokers at Newmark have been marketing spaces occupied by Coach, Stuart Weitzman and Tag Heuer on behalf of owner Brookfield. Other brokers suggest sꦗince LVMH is seeking spaces on Fifth Avenue, it could make an offer.

“The big fashion houses want the guarantee that they will have 🐻a fantastic presence on ✅a great corner in perpetuity,” said Matt Chmielecki of CBRE. 

IKEA's upcoming store in a tall glass tower at 570 Fifth Avenue, Midtown Manhattan, under construction
Ikea is DIYing its future store at 570 Fifth Ave. by investing in the construction of the new tower. INGKA

It’s a similar story downtown where Adelaide Polsinelli of Compass has two restaurants and some streetwear brands that want to buy locations in Little Italy and Soho. “Space is limited in Soho and𓃲 prices a🎉re going up,” she said.

Investor Isak Andic’s company bought a 19,000-square-foot store occupied by Cotton On at 512 Broadway (56 Crosby St.) for $26.9 million. Nearby, at 597 Broadway (170 Me🌳rcer St.), the Jackson Group paid $6.25 mill🐓ion for a store. Meanwhile, skin care brand Caudalie spent $9.7 million to buy a vacant store at 130 Greene St. 

But Ikea’s parent company is truly DIYing it: Not only is it buying 70,000 square feet — that will likely house a store — in the base of Extell’s new office tower at 570 Fifth Ave. at W. 47th St., it’s also inves🃏ting in the project. 

 “Investors want to have the ability to collect income from tenants a🔯nd not just have a vacant space.”

Bernadette Brennan, Serhant Commercial

“It’s a very st♋rong signal th꧑at retailers are sending to New York and the market by committing to New York and spending so much capital to control their real estate,” said Soutendijk. 

But it’s not just big fish gobbling up💖 sp♊aces. Smaller retailers are also buying. 

Bernadette Brennan, of Serhant Commercial, sold two small retail condos in the base of a new residential building at 165 Lexington Ave. on the corner of East 30th Street for nearly $1,400 per foot to owner-users. She has one left to go🍷. “Both were sold to the owners of small businesses who wanted to own instead of lease,” Brennan said. “We are seeing a desire for ownership.” 

Along with not paying “the exorbitant retail rents in Manhattan,” there are alsoꦇ tax advantages to ownership, Brennan said. One of the retail condo buyers had sold another property ཧand used the federal 1031 tax-free exchange proceeds to plow into the new store.

Religious groups, childcare companies, other non-profits🅠 and private schools, which don’t pay real estate taxes, are also in a stronger pos🎉ition to buy space, said Polsinelli. 

“I have one on the market where the taxes were through the roof and two non-profit users want it,” said Polsinelli of Compass. “They can pay more because they don’t have to factor in the real estate taxes.”  
 
But the retail buyi🐓ng spree isn’t only being spurred by owner-users.

Invest🎐ors are driving sales of occupied spaces, too. “Investors want to have the ability to collect income from tenants and not just have a vacant space,” Brennan said.