Real Estate

Historic Surrey hotel penthouse lists on NYC’s Upper East Side for $50M after a glamorous makeover

On the Upper East Side,ꦗ a $50 million penthouse atop the newly revamped Surrey hotel is set to make its debut.

The 5,200-square-foot duplex listing is the priciest re💫sidence in the Surrey, a nearly century-old building with a history as storied as its architecture, according to the .

This coveted address on East 76th Street near Madison Avenue has undergone a dramatic transformation under the direction of Reu꧋ben Brothers, a global investment com💟pany based in London, Geneva and Milan.

The nearly 5,200-square-foot duplex caps off a three-year restoration of the historic hotel, purchased by Reuben Brothers in 2020 during pandemic-driven bankruptcy proceedings. Noë & Associates with V1
The interiors are designed to reflect the building’s 1920s heritage. Noë & Associates with V1

The family-run firm acquired the Surrey in 2020 for 👍$150 million — 30% below its initial asking price — as the hotel waded through bankruptcy ami✃d the pandemic’s economic toll. The Surrey’s restoration, led by Reuben Brothers, has been three years in the making.

With the doors now reopened as “The Surrey, a Corinthia hotel,” the finishing touches on 14 luxury condos are exp🅠ected by early next year.

“We’re in a pretty good place,” Jamie🎃 Reuben, who represents the family business, told the Journal, coဣnfident that the right location and quality product will find the right buyers.

A shared roof deck for residents. Noë & Associates with V1
A rendering of the kitchen. Noë & Associates with V1

The penthouse boasts three bedrooms, three expansive private terraces with original 1920s parapets♕, and interiors featuring custom casement windows and white-oak floors that pay homage to the building’s pa꧂st.

The kitchen blends modern sophistication with heritage design, showcasing white-oak millwork and a Calacatta Go♕ld marble isla꧑nd.

The Reuben Brothers quietly sold or🌃 signed c꧒ontracts for the other 13 residences without any public marketing.

The formal dining room. Noë & Associates with V1
The formal living area with a fireplace. Noë & Associates with V1
One of three bathrooms. Noë & Associates with V1

Residents of these condos enjoy exclusive access to the h𒈔otel’s spa, fitness center, and priority key-fob access to elevators.

The Surrey’s past is a glamorous one.

It ဣonce drew high-society figures and long-term residents, including President John F. Kennedy, and actresses Bette Davis and Ethel Mer𒉰man.

The elevator entry. Noë & Associates with V1

Yet, just two years after opening, the building witnessed tragedy when tw𓆉o Guggenheim heirs fell from its rooftop, a moment memorialized in period newspapers.

In ✤recent decades, however, the Surrey fell into disrepair, leading to the Reubens’ acquisition as part of a US-based real estate strategy focused on prime properties bought at a discount.

“There were pretty serious questions about whether New York would ever return to being the financial mega-powerhouse it was pre-COV൩ID,” Reuben said. “It wasn’t something I subscribed to. I always believed it would come back.”

One of three bedrooms. Noë & Associates with V1
Another terrace. Noë & Associates with V1

Priced well below the $150 million condos on Billionaires’ Row, this Upper East Side gem is entering a luxury market in flux. According to Douglas Elliman, Manhattan’s third-quarter luxury sales dipped by 2.8% this year, and the median price dropped by 4% as buyers navigate fluctuating interest r🍌ates and th🐬e election year.

The building’s spa. Noë & Associates with V1
With exclusive access to the hotel’s amenities and private elevator service, the penthouse is positioned as a luxury haven in a fluctuating Manhattan market, which saw luxury sales dip by nearly 3% this quarter. Noë & Associates with V1

Despite the market shifts, Reuben remains 🌜optimistic about the Surrey🎀’s appeal to buyers seeking iconic addresses with unique histories.

“For the right product and the ꩵright location, there are buyers,” he said.