Metro
exclusive details

NYC Chinatown residents demand end to open streets program that turns neighborhood into ‘s–tshow’

Chinatown residents want to put the brakes on the return of open street parties to Canal Street this spring, saying the city’s move to close off part of the street turned their peaceful neighborhood into “spring break in Miami” for seven months of the year.

Last year, two blocks of Canal – between Orchard and Essex – were closed off to traffic from 3 to 11pm daily from April to October, allowing bars and restaurants to add hundreds of seats on the street, creating what residents described as a free-for-all.

They said adding 300 diners — with no extra toilets — was “psychotic.”

Residents said the restaurants allowed smoking at their tables in violation of city laws. Obtained by the New York Post

“The public urination is out of control. I’ve said to people, ‘Hey would you mind not peeing here?’ and they’ve said to me, ‘Why don’t I punch you in your f—ing mouth. It’s awful,” said neighbor Elizabeth Zalman.

Another neighbor said someone urinated in his building’s flowerpot. “It’s chaos,” said Bruce Torrey. “It’s a combat zone.”

Residents said partiers peeing on the street was a daily occurrence, with one here caught in the act on security camera. Obtained by the New York Post

A group of residents and business owners launched a stomach-churning campaign – using photos of public urination, puking and raucous behavior — to capture City Hall’s attention and deep-six a wine bar’s sidewalk-dining application.

It worked. In a rare move, City Hall rejected Le Dive’s request for 18 sidewalk seats.

But for neighbors, that’s just a symbolic victory. They expect Le Dive to get approval to put 87 seats on the street, along with half a dozen other bars and restaurants.

Le Dive put up a dining shed last week ahead of the season. The wine bar found itself at the center of a battle with Chinatown residents. Matthew McDermott

Jon Neidich, owner of Le Dive, told The Post the restaurants are being unfairly targeted.

“The block parties and stuff like that — that didn’t come from any of the restaurants. Our business is having people seated and serving them,” he said.

The residents’ focus now is trying to get the city to put limits on the Canal Open Streets program

Elizabeth Zalman said it feels like the community is policing the restaurants. Helayne Seidman

They say partiers inevitably end up spilling out onto side streets, leaving behind broken glass, cigarette butts and various bodily fluids.

“You see these little grandmas the next morning sweeping up the streets because they’re going to get a fine from the Sanitation Department saying ‘this is a s–tshow’,” said Zalman, who lives on Orchard Street.

Frank Farooq says many of his customers come by car to pick up heavy equipment. Helayne Seidman

Shop owners say they are losing customers.

“It screwed up my business,” vented Frank Farooq, who has owned Hi-Tech Electronic Service Center on Canal for 32 years. “They block my entrance and my customers cannot come.”

The low point came on Oct. 4, when a 26-year-old man was slashed in the face after a dispute.

Residents shared this photo of puke in front of a Canal St funeral home as part of their campaign. Obtained by the New York Post

“Residents and business owners were left to clean up the blood while diners looked on, drinking their Pet Nat,” one resident told The Post.

The community’s main ask to the DOT is to reduce the number of seats restaurants are allowed to add on Canal by half. They also want the party to end an hour earlier, and to have no seating on the south side of Canal to make way for an emergency lane.

So far, restaurants have agreed to limit the party to four days a week instead of seven. The DOT confirmed Canal Open Streets was approved to operate from Thursdays to Sundays for the 2025 season.